Verified deal Price found: October 23, 2026
Round-trip nonstop flights from New York (Newark) to Anguilla for December 18 to 25, 2026 start at US$442. This price is low for the route, about US$253 below what this trip usually costs. That is Christmas week on one of the Caribbean’s most exclusive islands.
- Route
- New York Newark (EWR) to Anguilla (AXA), round trip
- Dates
- Depart December 18, return December 25, 2026
- Price
- From US$442 per person, taxes included
- Usual price
- About US$695 (Google Flights estimate)
- Saving
- About 36%
- Flights
- Nonstop both ways on BermudAir, about 4 h 40 min out and 4 h 50 min back
- Bags
- Economy Light fare includes a personal item and a carry-on up to 10 kg. First checked bag about US$130.
- Changes
- Non-refundable. Changes are allowed for a fee.
Airlines and prices
| Airline | Round trip from | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| BermudAir | US$442 | Nonstop EWR to AXA. Out 11:00 AM, arrives 4:40 PM. Back 7:10 PM, arrives 11:00 PM. Embraer 190 jet. |
| BermudAir (another booking site) | US$541 | Same nonstop flights, Economy Light fare, shown at a higher price on another booking site the same day. |
| American Airlines | US$955 | 1 stop in Miami. Basic Economy, no changes. |
Booking sites can show different totals for the same flights, so compare the final price, with any bags you need, before you pay. Only a few seats were left at this fare when we checked.
Why Anguilla at Christmas
Late December is the start of Anguilla’s peak season: dry, sunny and about 28°C, with calm turquoise water on beaches like Shoal Bay and Meads Bay. Hotels and villas fill up early for the holidays, and flights usually cost much more, because there are very few direct options from the US. This is the only nonstop on the route.
Planning your trip? Read our Anguilla travel guide for the best beaches, things to do and itineraries.
Prices change quickly and are set by the airlines and booking sites, not by TripIntel. The price shown when you book is the one that applies. Fares were checked across several booking sites on October 23, 2026.